There are so many choices when picking the best blue cheese dressing. There are usually a lot of different kinds of salad dressings in the salad dressing aisle at the grocery store. Blue cheese dressing is no different. It’s hard to tell which brand will work best for you because each adds something different to this tangy, creamy dressing.
There are many ways to use blue cheese dressing. It can be a salad sauce, a dip for wings, or even a topping for burgers. How do you make a great blue cheese dressing? It all comes down to how creamy it is, how strong the blue cheese tastes, and how the texture is.
Some people like sauces with big chunks of blue cheese, while others might like smoother with a milder flavor. A blue cheese sauce is available for everyone, no matter what they want.
I tested 11 different blue cheese dressings from food stores to help you decide which ones to buy. To find the best ones, they were all graded on taste, texture, and the number of ways they could be used. After this test, it took a lot of work to rank them from worst to best.
The Cheap End: Dresses That Didn’t Hit the Mark
The real bleu cheese dressing and dip from Cindy’s Kitchen
That said, even though it cost $6.49, this one immediately had significant problems. It was hard to pour from the glass bottle, and you had to move around to get the dressing out. The bad news is that the problems continued with the packing.
Look: It had many chunks, but the dressing in the middle of them was thin and off-white.
Taste: It was surprisingly boring, even though there were a lot of chunks. The dressing had no blue solid cheese or spice flavors, so it had a bland finish. The taste improved if you could get a chunk in your bite, but it wasn’t enough to save this one.
365 by Whole Foods Blue Cheese Dressing Chunky
This brand is sold at Whole Foods for $3.99, but it didn’t live up to our expectations.
Look: The sauce was skinny, and it was hard to find big bits of blue cheese. It wasn’t thick; it was more like water.
Taste: It wasn’t solid, which could be good for people who dislike blue cheese’s strong flavor. That being said, this one won’t do for people who want a sharp, sour taste.
Blue Cheese Dressing from Wegmans
The blue cheese sauce at Wegmans, which costs $2.50, wasn’t as good as most of the company’s other products.
Look: you could barely see any blue cheese chunks, and the substance was more like ranch dressing than blue cheese dressing.
Not sure what to say about the taste—it was more like ranch than blue cheese for some reason. It wasn’t right because it only had a tiny hint of blue cheese.
Good, but it could be better.
Blue Cheese Dressing and Dip by Marzetti
This one is great because it can be used as a dip and a sandwich. It cost $3.98 and was more of a dip than a salad dressing.
Look at how dense and thick it was—almost like mayonnaise—and how many cheese chunks there were.
Taste: The blue cheese taste was strong, but it didn’t have the sour and tangy punch that makes blue cheese salads great. Because of how it felt overall, it was hard to picture it as a salad sauce.
Blue cheese chunky dressing and dip from Lighthouse
For $5.29, Litehouse has a good combination of dressing that can be used as a sauce and a dip.
Look: It says it’s thick, but I saw little bits of blue cheese spread out.
Taste: The taste was mostly ranch, with the blue cheese-less noticeable. It was smooth and creamy, but it lacked the tang that blue cheese fans love.
The Best: You should try these blue cheese dressings.
Blue cheese chunky dressing from Ken’s Steak House
Most of the time, Ken’s Steak House goods are good, and this one was no different. At $2.94, it’s also a fair price.
Look at how creamy and thick it is. The chunks are small and don’t make it too much.
Taste: The taste was perfect, even though there were small chunks. The blue cheese was strong, but the dressing base’s creaminess balanced it. It’s a good choice for both salads and dips.
Toby’s Blue Cheese Dip and Dressing
At $5.49, this sauce is another great choice that can be used for many things. Its great mix of tastes makes it great for salads and dipping vegetables.
Look at this: it’s thicker than most, like a veggie dip, and the blue cheese chunks are small but spread out evenly.
Regarding taste, Toby says this dressing goes well with just about anything. There are strong notes of sour tang and blue cheese, and the creamy base really brings it all together.
Wishbone Blue Cheese Dressing with Chunks
Wish-Bone is a well-known name in grocery stores, and this dressing, which costs $2.38, shows that good taste doesn’t have to cost a lot of money.
It looks smooth and creamy, with bits of blue cheese mixed in.
Taste: This dressing tastes strongly of blue cheese and is sour and salty. It is rich and creamy without being too thick to be used for both salads and dips. Wish-Bone has a solid blue cheese taste balanced by the cool dressing. The low price makes it even more attractive.
The Best Blue Cheese Dressing: A Winner That Is Rich and Well-Tuned
Chunky Blue Cheese Yogurt Dressing and Dip from Bolthouse Farms
Bolthouse Farms’ product, which costs $3.99, won the taste test. This blue cheese dressing has everything you could want in a creamy and sour combination.
Look: The texture is smooth, and small pieces of blue cheese are spread out equally. It’s easy to pour and doesn’t stick together like some thicker kinds.
Taste: This is where Bolthouse Farms shines. The sauce is just the right amount of creamy and tangy from the blue cheese without being too strong. This sauce can be used as a salad dressing and a dip, making it very useful. Additionally, it is a better choice because it has fewer calories than other types.
Final Thoughts
Before you go shopping for the blue cheese dressing, think about what you want to do with it. Would you like to pair a salad with something lighter and more balanced in flavor? Wish-Bone or Ken’s Steak House might be a good choice. Toby’s or Bolthouse Farms are great picks for people who want a richer, thicker sauce for dipping.
Ultimately, the best blue cheese dressing has a strong taste and a smooth, creamy texture. To satisfy your blue cheese needs, you can drizzle these sauces over a salad, dip vegetables in them, or serve them with wings.